In this dueling blog, Moviefone's Oscarologist Jack Mathews and indieWire's Anne Thompson discuss the recently-announced Producers Guild of America nominations and ask the question: Do such sci-fi movies as 'District 9' and 'Star Trek,' which made the PGA's 10-best ballot, really belong in the Oscar Hunt?

Read the repartee on the jump.
categories Features, Movies, Oscars, Awards