Hope Davis Awards

Chicago Film Critics Association

Year Result Award Movie
2003 Nominated Chicago Film Critics Association Best Actress
American Splendor

Hollywood Foreign Press Association

Year Result Award Movie
2003 Nominated Hollywood Foreign Press Association Best Performance by an Actress in a Supporting Role in a Motion Picture
American Splendor

Independent Spirit Awards

Year Result Award Movie
2008 Won Independent Spirit Awards Robert Altman Award
Synecdoche, New York
2003 Nominated Independent Spirit Awards Best Supporting Actress
The Secret Lives of Dentists

National Society of Film Critics

Year Result Award Movie
2003 Won National Society of Film Critics Best Actress - Runner-up
The Secret Lives of Dentists

New York Film Critics Circle

Year Result Award Movie
2003 Won New York Film Critics Circle Best Actress
American Splendor
2003 Won New York Film Critics Circle Best Actress
The Secret Lives of Dentists