Opening in theaters on November 20th is 'Elsinore', directed by Simon Stone ('The Dig'), written by Stephen Beresford ('Tolkien'), and starring Andrew Scott ('Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery'), Billie Piper ('Scoop'), Johnny Flynn ('A Prayer for the Dying'), Joe Locke ('Agatha All Along'), Peter Mullan ('Westworld'), and Oscar winner Olivia Colman ('The Favourite').
Related Article: 'Elsinore' Interview: Andrew Scott and Billie Piper
Initial Thoughts
It seems like we don’t have an awards season without a film somehow related to ‘Hamlet,’ but in the case of ‘Elsinore,’ we should be so lucky to have even one like this. Based on the life of late actor Ian Charleson, ‘Elsinore’ is at its most basic level, a saga of triumph over tragedy. But there is so much more going on beneath its surface, and all of it is tied together by one of the most breathtaking performances of the year.
Andrew Scott has already stunned and amazed in projects like ‘All of Us Strangers’ and ‘Ripley,’ but his work in ‘Elsinore’ is nothing short of titanic. He’s not just playing Charleson, but he’s playing Charleson playing Hamlet. He’s also funny, earnest, cynical, self-deprecating, and full of rage and sadness. And though his story doesn’t have a happy ending, it fills our hearts even as it breaks them into pieces.
Story and Direction
It’s 1989 and Scottish actor Ian Charleson is best known for playing Olympic athlete Eric Liddell eight years earlier in the Oscar-winning ‘Chariots of Fire.’ Unsatisfied with his career since then, Charleson yearns to play Hamlet at the National Theater in London and finally seems to get his chance when another up-and-coming actor, Daniel Day-Lewis, quits the latest production in the middle of a performance.
But Charleson has also been diagnosed with AIDS, and his doctor, Margaret Johnson (Olivia Colman) advises him against taking on the role because of the stamina it will require and the toll it will take on his health. Charleson forges ahead anyway, with the blessing and full knowledge of the play’s director, Richard Eyre (Johnny Flynn). Dividing his time between treatments at the hospital and rehearsals at the theatre, Charleson begins a race against time and mortality to give his career and life a chance to leave something behind.
Director Simon Stone and writer Stephen Beresford could have easily crossed the line into sentimentality with ‘Elsinore,’ and on one or two occasions the film veers in that direction, only to pull itself back. For the most part, this is instead an intensely emotional, raw piece of work not just because of the situation that Charleson finds himself in, but because of the external circumstances as well.
One of his early directors, Derek Jarman, takes him to task for not coming out – which Charleson has not even done at that point with his parents. This is 1989, after all, and the “gay plague” stigma was still very much in effect at the time. The disappearance of many young men, including many in Charleson’s circle, is a haunting reminder of how AIDS was at the time this terrible secret no one wanted to deal with. That Charleson struggles with all this, while fighting the ravages of the disease that is gradually claiming his body and preparing for the role of his life, is what makes ‘Elsinore’ so gripping.
But the film also offers – like another new movie out this month, ‘All of a Sudden’ – glimpses of deep compassion and humanity, whether they’re from Charleson’s friends, his doctor, the staff at the hospital, or his fellow cast members and larger theatre community that rallies around him. The sheer strength of Charleson’s will, the depth of the tragedy affecting him and others while so much of society looks away, and the powerful ability of art to bring people together and heal one’s soul, are what make ‘Elsinore,’ in the end, an overwhelming experience.
Cast and Performances
What more can be said about Andrew Scott? He is simply one of our best actors, and his performance here is nothing short of monumental. All of the many shadings of Ian Charleson are brought to life, and at the same time Scott/Charleson are also finding their way through a performance of ‘Hamlet’ that is still remembered today. Watching Scott navigate and embrace the layers of the role – the actor playing the actor playing one of the most challenging roles in theatre history, while literally staring death in the face – is watching a master at work.
This is Scott’s show, but we also get the usual amazing work from Olivia Colman (two for two this fall with this and ‘Wicker') as the caring yet no-nonsense Dr. Johnson, Johnny Flynn as a humane Richard Eyre, David Dawson as a bitterly hurt Jarman, and Billie Piper as Charleson’s effervescent bestie Patsy. And we also have to mention Peter Mullan and Georgie Glen as Charleson’s parents in just a handful of scenes that are just devastating.
Final Thoughts
It’s been noted that there are no visual records of Ian Charleson’s run as Hamlet, so not even Scott – who has become famous for playing the Dane himself – could have something on which to base his version of Charleson’s performance. That makes Scott’s work here even more stunning, especially as Stone crosscuts between Charleson’s deepening ill health and his relentless drive to master the role.
This all builds to a finale during which a number of the normally stoic critics at our screening could be heard audibly choking back tears. But any tears that one may shed while watching ‘Elsinore’ are not just those of sadness, but of awe at the humanity on display and the legacy of the two human beings – one living, one now a memory – that lie at the heart of this poignant, transformative film.
‘Elsinore’ receives a score of 95 out of 100.
What is the plot of ‘Elsinore’?
Facing his own mortality with unflinching honesty, wit, and grace, Ian Charleson delivers a courageous performance that becomes a source of healing and inspiration for those around him.
Who is in the cast of 'Elsinore'?
- Andrew Scott as Ian Charleson
- Olivia Colman as Margaret Johnson
- Billie Piper as Patsy Pollock
- Sadie Soverall as Alice
- Johnny Flynn as Richard Eyre
- Luke Thompson as Georgie
- Monica Dolan as Linda Tolhurst
- Joe Locke as Nicholas
- Matthew Beard as Sean Mathias
- David Dawson as Derek Jarman
- Peter Mullan as Jack Charleson
- Georgie Glen as Jean Charleson
- Juliet Stevenson as Sylvia Syms
- Danny Webb as Michael Bryant
- Jamie Bogyo as Jeremy Northam
- Alyth Ross as Stella Gonet
- David Rintoul as John Castle
List of Andrew Scott Movies and TV Shows:
- 'Saving Private Ryan' (1998)
- 'Band of Brothers' (2001)
- 'The Comeback' (2005-2026)
- 'John Adams' (2008)
- 'Sherlock' (2010-2017)
- 'Locke' (2014)
- 'Spectre' (2015)
- 'Victor Frankenstein' (2015)
- 'Fleabag' (2016-2019)
- 'Alice Through the Looking Glass' (2016)
- 'Denial' (2016)
- 'His Dark Materials' (2019-2023)
- 'A Dark Place' (2019)
- '1917' (2019)
- 'Catherine Called Birdy' (2022)
- 'All of Us Strangers' (2024)
- 'Ripley' (2024)
- 'Back in Action' (2025)
- 'Blue Moon' (2025)
- 'Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery' (2025)
- 'Pressure' (2026)
- 'Elsinore' (2026)
