Season 1 Plot
Nine of the best hyper-realistic cake artists around try to trick celebrity judges with their spooktacular realistic cakes as they compete in a do-or-die competition to take home their share of the prize pot and the title of Is It Cake? Halloween champion! With tricks and treats at every turn, these frighteningly realistic cakes will leave you asking the ultimate question... Is It Cake?
Is It Cake? Halloween Season 1 aired on October 8th, 2025.
Season 1 Episodes
1. Cakes to Die For
The competition begins as the bakers craft convincingly creepy dolls, clowns, and ravens. Guest judges: Pete Holmes, Chelsea Peretti and Ravi V. Patel.
2. Gettin' Witchy With It!
Mikey's fickle "cauldron of destiny" decides which witchy object the bakers must make. Guest judges: Melissa Joan Hart, Jack McBrayer and Yvonne Orji.
3. Is it Wonka?
The bakers tape into their pure imagination and whip up whimsical Willy Wonka cakes. Guest judges: Harvey Guillén, Kevin Nealon and Gillian Jacobs.
4. A Scary Good Winner
Vultures, gargoyles and gravestones, oh my! Which baker will take home the grand prize? Guest judges: Ron Funches, Rachel Feinstein and Whitney Cummings.
