Based on 16 Critics
critic reviews ( 3 )
fan reviews ( 58 )
See all critic reviews on
  • August 11, 2009 KristyandJay
    Report This User

    this movie was not bery interesting at all and had a really bad story line. No wonder Lindsy is now a nobody in Hollywood with crap movies like this one.

  • August 02, 2008 astboi88
    Report This User

    I have found that many people have underestimated this movie. i really liked it. It had just enough dopey acting in it to keep me intrigued. congrats on the movie...

  • July 02, 2008 clandestinebatt
    Report This User

    this is a movie that is stupid unless you understand it. there are many significant things that if you dont comprehend the importance then it will make no sence and seem incoherent. for example, the specific limbs the killer cut off were the limbs that allowed the victims to play the piano. the trophies in both girls rooms were for the piano, he was their coach and he was obsessed with winning, when the girls quit he took revenge on them by not allowing them to play ever again. everything was blue because it was the color of a first prize ribbon. the other things were red because it is what the killer would perceive to be not good enough. it was an overall good movie if you pay close attention to the details.