"We are those 'The Craft'-loving weirdos, mister." Well, half of us are, the other half want to invoke Manon and get back the hour and 40 minutes spent watching the movie.

Tim picked the (apparently divisive) '90s teen witch thriller, which stars perhaps the most '90s cast ever assembled: Robin Tunney, Neve Campbell, Fairuza Balk, Rachel True, and Skeet Ulrich. Topics discussed include obvious wigs, Catholic schools with no rules, terrible special effects, terrible parents, Breckin Meyer's stellar douche acting, and the hell-on-Earth that is Los Angeles. (Seriously, there are a lot of trash fires and snake-loving ne'er-do-wells in this movie's version of L.A.)

Next week's movie, "John Carter," comes courtesy of special guest Drew Taylor, who will somehow try to convince us that watching a loincloth-clad Taylor Kitsch learn how to battle aliens in low gravity for two hours and 12 minutes is time well spent.

Listen to CAN'T WAIT! A Movie Lover's Podcast Episode 16: 'The Craft'Total runtime: 54:02

Subscribe to the CAN'T WAIT! podcast:

Have thoughts/feelings/feedback about the podcast? Have a movie you really, really want us to watch and talk about? Hit us up on Facebook, Twitter, or Instagram with the hashtag #CANTWAIT.

CAN'T WAIT! A Movie Lover's Podcast by Moviefone celebrates Hollywood's guiltiest pleasures by taking a fresh look at critically ignored movies and giving them a second chance at life. Join Moviefone editors Tim Hayne, Rachel Horner, Phil Pirrello, and Tony Maccio as they extol the virtues and expose the failings (with love!) of nostalgic movies.