R| 1 hr. 37 min.
In a film based on actual events, Albert Fish (Patrick Bauchau) visits a teen boy seeking a job and offers him work at a county house in upstate New York. Then, with the blessing of the family, Fish takes the boy's younger sister, Grace Budd (Lexi Ainsworth), to what he says is a family celebration. Fish kills the girl but escapes, until police Detective Will King (Jack Conley), prompted by an anonymous tip, closes in on Fish, uncovering evidence that Grace was not his only victim.