Moviefone logo
Trending
'Wicked: For Good' Trailer
'Zootopia 2' Teaser Trailer
'Superman' Trailer
'Ironheart' Trailer
Buy TicketsHighlightsNew MoviesTV ShowsStreamingMovie ChartsVideosWhat to WatchIn TheatersMovie TheatersComing SoonMovie ReviewsMoviefone TVMade In HollywoodNewsCelebritiesNetflixPrime Video
SinnersSinnersThe AmateurThe AmateurFreaksFreaksI Know What You Did Last SummerI Know What You Did Last SummerDropDropUNTAMEDUNTAMEDThe Summer I Turned PrettyThe Summer I Turned PrettyStar Trek: Strange New WorldsStar Trek: Strange New WorldsThe InstituteThe InstituteBallardBallard
Words of War - Sean Penn Exclusive Interview
Words of War
Lilo & Stitch - Car Ride Scene
Lilo & Stitch
Ironheart - Official Trailer
Ironheart
The Fantastic Four: First Steps - Höt Aftershave Promo Poster
The Fantastic Four: First Steps
Elio - Freeze Frame Clip
Elio
Mortal Kombat II - Johnny Cage Character Poster
Mortal Kombat II
Elio - Communiverse Clip
Elio
Dexter: Resurrection Season 1 - Uma Thurman Character Poster
Dexter: Resurrection
The Friend - Bill Murray Exclusive Interview
The Friend
Mortal Kombat II - Official Teaser Poster
Mortal Kombat II
Superman - Official Teaser Trailer
Superman
Stranger Things Season 5 - Official Poster
Stranger Things
Cleaner - Daisy Ridley Exclusive Interview
Cleaner
Mortal Kombat II - Jax Character Poster
Mortal Kombat II
Squid Game: Season 3 - Final Round Teaser Clip
Squid Game
Murderbot Season 1 - Alexander Skarsgård as Murderbot
Murderbot
  1. News
  2. ›Features

14 Actors You Totally Forgot Were on 'Supernatural'

Sharon Knolle
May 26, 2016 - 1 min read

Several famous (or about to be famous) faces have appeared on the long-running "Supernatural" as demons, vamps, witches, and victims -- but do you remember them?

Sarah Shahi, Season 1

The actress, who currently plays Sameen Shaw on "Person of Interest," was the mysterious (and deadly) Woman in White in the pilot episode. Shahi was also the star of the "Nancy Drew" reboot that was nixed by CBS for "skewing too female."

Cory Monteith, Season 1

The future "Glee" star was a camper who gets slaughtered by a Native American spirit known as a "Wendigo" in the episode of the same name.

Alden Ehrenreich, Season 1

The actor, who was recently cast as the young Han Solo, was only 15 when he played "Ben Collins" in the Season 1 episode "Wendigo," a teen looking for his lost brother. His older sister and Dean get captured by the deadly Wendigo, and Ben and Sam rush to their rescue.

Linda Blair, Season 2

The star of "The Exorcist" played a Baltimore cop in "The Usual Suspects," where Dean is in custody as the prime suspect in a bizarre double murder. She ends up turning to Sam to solve the case and, yes, a joke about pea soup is made.

Gary Cole, Season 2

When people begin dying on a horror movie set in the "Hollywood Babylon" episode, Sam and Dean drop in as production assistants to help solve the case. There, they encounter the "Office Space" and "Veep" star, a clueless producer who ends up being one of the ghost's victims.

Sterling K. Brown, Seasons 2 & 3

Gung-ho vampire hunter Gordon, who became a vampire himself, appeared in four episodes from 2006-2007. Brown went on to roles in "Army Wives" and "Person of Interest," but really broke out with his performance as Christopher Darden on FX's "American Crime Story: The People v. O.J. Simpson."

Aldis Hodge, Season 2

The actor, who starred as MC Ren in "Straight Outta Compton," played Jake Talley, one of the "Special Children," including Sam, who are abducted and forced to battle to the death in the two-part 2007 episode "All Hell Breaks Loose." Hodge also has a recurring role on "Turn: Washington's Spies."

Ashley Benson, Season 4

Two years before landing a lead role on "Pretty Little Liars," Benson played a cheerleader who's really a centuries-old witch in "It's the Great Pumpkin, Sam." She summons the demon Samhain, who promptly kills her.

Candice King, Season 4

The "Vampire Diaries" star (billed here as "Candice Accola") was the rare guest star who wasn't a vampire, ghost, or demon. She appeared in "After School Special" as a girl Dean once dated in high school.

Bellamy Young, Season 5

The "Scandal" First Lady appeared in "Sympathy for the Devil" as Sarah, one of the many vessels for Lucifer. Before she was murdered, she was married to Nick (Mark Pellegrino), who became the most familiar incarnation of Lucifer on the series.

Paris Hilton, Season 5

Fans were in an uproar when it was announced that the celebrity heiress was going to appear on the show. In the "Fallen Idols" episode, Hilton (along with Abraham Lincoln) is just one incarnation of the "Leshi," an ancient Eastern European forest god who relies on human sacrifice to survive.

Sarah Drew, Season 5

In "Swap Meat," the "Grey's Anatomy" star played a high school student whose friends dabble in the black arts: They summon a demon, who ends up possessing her. You've never seen Dr. Kepner rip out someone's heart and then lick the blood off her fingers!

Mike Farrell, Season 8

The "M*A*S*H" star appeared in the "Hunteri Heroici" episode as a psychic capable of altering reality with his visions, resulting in several people dying in a gruesomely cartoonish fashion.

Lesley Nicol, Season 10

Don't recognize this evil, cleaver-wielding witch from the episode "About a Boy?" (She turns adults, including Dean, into children so she can eat them.) She's better known for her turn as a much nicer cook, Mrs. Patmore on "Downton Abbey." What would Mr. Carson say?

supernaturalthe cw
FeaturesBest TV Shows Ever
Sharon Knolle
Article by Sharon Knolle
Freelance Writer

Sharon has been writing for Moviefone since 2009 and has also written for IMDB, USA Today, TV Guide and Forces of Geek.

Related News

'The Pope's Exorcist' Interview: Russell Crowe
'The Pope's Exorcist' Interview: Russell Crowe
Movie Review: ‘Umma’
Movie Review: ‘Umma’
Iris K. Shim Talks ‘Umma’
Iris K. Shim Talks ‘Umma’
Phil Morris Talks ‘Ghosts of the Ozark’
Phil Morris Talks ‘Ghosts of the Ozark’
Jackson Rathbone Talks ‘Warhunt’
Jackson Rathbone Talks ‘Warhunt’
The CW Reveals Fall Premiere Dates for 'Supernatural,' 'Batwoman,' More
The CW Reveals Fall Premiere Dates for 'Supernatural,' 'Batwoman,' More

More News on Moviefone

CBS to end ‘The Late Show with Stephen Colbert’
CBS to end ‘The Late Show with Stephen Colbert’
Ryan Gosling and Will Ferrell Starring in ‘Tough Guys’
Ryan Gosling and Will Ferrell Starring in ‘Tough Guys’
‘Guns Up' Exclusive Interview: Luis Guzman
‘Guns Up' Exclusive Interview: Luis Guzman
'Saint Clare' Exclusive Interview: Bella Thorne
'Saint Clare' Exclusive Interview: Bella Thorne
Taika Waititi Developing New ‘Judge Dredd’ Movie
Taika Waititi Developing New ‘Judge Dredd’ Movie
Cameron Diaz to Star in Action Comedy ‘Bad Day’
Cameron Diaz to Star in Action Comedy ‘Bad Day’
  • New Movies
  • Movies In Theaters
  • Movies Coming Soon
  • Movies Streaming Now
  • TV Shows
  • Best Movies
  • Best TV Shows

Follow Moviefone

FacebookXInstagramYouTubeLinkedInTikTokRSS

Movie and TV Reviews

Superman poster
Superman
Movie Review
90
Ballard poster
Ballard
Season 1
TV Show Review
55
The Sandman poster
The Sandman
Season 2
TV Show Review
70

Top Movies

Sinners poster
Sinners
Dance with the devil.
76
The Amateur poster
The Amateur
Don't underestimate him.
70
Freaks poster
Freaks
They look just like us.
68

Top Series

UNTAMED poster
UNTAMED
86
The Summer I Turned Pretty poster
The Summer I Turned Pretty
We'll always have summer.
82
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds poster
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds
The frontier awaits.
81

Latest Trailers

'Platonic' Season 2 Trailer1:56'Platonic' Season 2 Trailer
'Mortal Kombat II' Trailer2:32'Mortal Kombat II' Trailer
'Hoppers' Teaser Trailer2:00'Hoppers' Teaser Trailer
'After the Hunt' Trailer2:59'After the Hunt' Trailer
'Stranger Things' Season 5 Teaser Trailer2:46'Stranger Things' Season 5 Teaser Trailer
'The Map That Leads to You' Trailer2:31'The Map That Leads to You' Trailer
Moviefone logo

Join our Newsletter

Movies
Best Movies to WatchTop Movies Right NowWhat to Watch TodayMovies in Theaters This WeekUpcoming Movie Releases2025 Movie Release CalendarBrowse Movies by Keywords
TV Shows
Best TV Shows to BingeTop TV Shows Right NowNew TV Shows This WeekTrending TV ShowsTV Shows by KeywordsLatest TV Show TrailersExclusive TV Show Clips
Streaming
Streaming Now & UpcomingWhat's New on NetflixTop Picks on Prime VideoNew Releases on Disney+Popular Movies on HuluWhat to Watch on MaxStreaming Now on Apple TV+
Showtimes
Showtimes & TicketsMovie Showtimes in LAMovie Showtimes in DallasMovie Showtimes in New YorkAll U.S. Movie TheatersAMC Theatres ListingsCinemark Theatres Listings
Videos
Movie & TV Show VideosLatest Movie TrailersMoviefone TV EpisodesMade in Hollywood InterviewsExclusive Movie ClipsCelebrity InterviewsMade In Hollywood Teen
Movie GenresSummer MoviesHoliday MoviesThriller MoviesRomance MoviesMystery MoviesCrime Movies
TV GenresDocumentary TV ShowsHorror TV ShowsCrime TV ShowsDrama TV ShowsAnimation TV ShowsMystery TV Shows
NewsMovie NewsTV NewsMovie PhotosBehind the ScenesBest Movies EverMarvel Cinematic Universe
CelebritiesAna de ArmasLiam NeesonTimothée ChalametDaniel RadcliffeBrie LarsonNatalie Portman
Movie ReviewsWickedRed OneGladiator IIWallace & Gromit: Vengeance Most FowlHereticWe Live in Time
FacebookXInstagramYouTubeLinkedInTikTokRSS
AboutContact UsSitemapTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy
Copyright © 2025 Moviefone Media LLC
Asset 1This product uses the TMDb API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDb.